Breck wins Grey Belt argument in St Helens appeal
The housebuilder has been granted consent to deliver 51 affordable homes off Fleet Street in Parr following the council’s refusal of the plans a year ago.
Breck Homes, working with landowner Northern Trust, lodged an application to develop the four-acre Green Belt site in March 2025.
The developer argued the site meets the criteria for Grey Belt but St Helens Council’s planning committee disagreed, rejecting the plan for six reasons.
Now, a planning inspector has ruled that the refusal be overturned, agreeing with the appellant that the site is Grey Belt and that St Helens Council had overestimated its housing land supply position.
The scheme, which will be managed by Jigsaw Homes, can now go ahead.
Phil Dolan, managing director for the North West at Breck Homes, said: “By the time the appeal was heard, the council and Breck had reached agreement on the other reasons for refusal of the planning application.
“The only remaining item of contention was whether the proposed scheme would constitute inappropriate development in the Green Belt, having regard to the relevant development plan policies and the National Planning Policy Framework.
“We successfully demonstrated that the site qualifies as Grey Belt and would therefore not constitute inappropriate development in the Green Belt. We also demonstrated the unmet need for affordable housing and the local planning authority’s lack of a five-year deliverable housing land supply.”
Breck and Northern Trust’s project team includes Trevor Bridge Associates, LDE, UES, IGE Consulting, Enviro Solution, Prime Transport Planning, Rachel Hacking Ecology, and Urban Green.
Kings Chambers, De Pol Associates, Emery Planning, and Tetlow King advised on the appeal.
The appeal reference number is 6010284. The St Helens Council planning portal reference for the original application is P/2025/0174.

